DigsHome | Help Digs Help You: Take our survey
  DigsBoards
  outside world
  Keeping your name or taking hubby's? (Page 8)

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone!
This topic is 8 pages long:   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8 
next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Keeping your name or taking hubby's?
ralphyr
Housemate
posted 01-07-2005 02:38 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for ralphyr   Click Here to Email ralphyr     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Now that I'm less than 3 months away from being a Mrs (but I must say that I don't like the sound of being a Mistress of anyone) I'm thinking of the name change. Is it easier just to do it all in one hit or phase it in. Would It confuse me to go by two names and have to carry both my birthcerticate and marriage cert around me where ever I go?
However I'll be changing my digsname 'cause that is made from my surname and anyway it makes me out to be a bit blokey

IP: Logged

breana
Housemate
posted 01-07-2005 02:59 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for breana   Click Here to Email breana     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
but we LIKE calling you ralphy....

IP: Logged

jenjoaquin
Subletter
posted 01-28-2005 01:56 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for jenjoaquin   Click Here to Email jenjoaquin     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I have been happily married for 3 years, I NEVER- ever considered changing my last name - You do have to expect that certain people are always going to refer to you as Mr & Mrs. So and So (and that's okay!)
I say that if you love your name then you should keep it!

ps. I should note that this decision was made ALOT easier by the fact that we are not having children

[This message has been edited by jenjoaquin (edited 01-28-2005).]

IP: Logged

bekkaboo
Housesitter
posted 01-28-2005 02:15 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for bekkaboo   Click Here to Email bekkaboo     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by zazzera:
I would love for us both to change our names to something new for a fresh start. Any suggestions on coming up with a new family name??? (leaving no trace of the old ones)


Just wanted to bring this back up, b/c this is what boy & I plan to do (long story, I think I posted the reason why earlier in this thread.) I don't know how to LOOK for a name - there's not really a family name in either of our families that he'll agree to take, he wants to start completely new. I want something that will MEAN something to both of us, yet not sound like we obviously made it up. Also, I am getting worried about the explaining-things-to-family part, and also starting to wonder what I might tell any children we might have, when they want to know about the history of the "Whatever" family.

Also, he's completely shot down my suggestions of O'Hooligan, McHuggensnuggler, and Spiderman (pronounced SPIDD-er-munn).

IP: Logged

gemini
Housemate
posted 01-28-2005 02:49 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for gemini   Click Here to Email gemini     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I heard an interview on some NPR show one day with some expert about some kind of scientific stuff, and the the fellow they were interviewing was named Dr. Lovely. I'm not sure what his first name was, but good god, I've never wanted to change my name so badly in my life. Dr. Lovely. I freaking love it!!!!!

So I vote you change your name to Mr. and Mrs. Lovely.

IP: Logged

dcgrrrl1979
Housemate
posted 01-28-2005 03:07 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for dcgrrrl1979     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by bekkaboo:

Spiderman (pronounced SPIDD-er-munn).

Hee!
Diggs would be a lovely family name, IMHO.

IP: Logged

TinyGirl
Housemate
posted 01-28-2005 03:27 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for TinyGirl     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

Originally posted by zitem:
I questioned the tradition of using the "wedding march" as my "down the aisle song" because it was written in Nazi Germany and played as Jews were marched into the incinerators (History of Music 101 -very sad discovery I wished I never knew).

[QUOTE]Originally posted by pollyhyper:
Never heard this...please tell me more!
And welcome to Digs!
[/QUOTE

Actually, I believe you are referring to the wedding march by Richard Wagner? He was alive during that later part of the 19th century. His music was used as propaganda by the Nazis, but he was not a Nazi himself as he was actually born much earlier and wasn't alive at the time. Hitler et al used many German composers as part of their twisted propaganda system (i.e., Bach was a great German 'cause he worked hard and churned out lots of compositions). What you may be referring to was the practice of having Jewish orchestras at the concentration camps to help the people march to their deaths. So, in a since, they may have been marching while hearing the "Wedding March" but it also could have been a Brahms Symphony. *Whew* I recommend the book "Music and the Third Reich" by Erik Levi for more information.

Note: I respect your choice of not choosing this piece for this reason, it's just the wee music-history person in me can't pass up the chance to jump in!

sorry for the interruption--I will now happily live vicariously through all your beautiful weddings!

[This message has been edited by TinyGirl (edited 01-28-2005).]

ETA: an "i" and insert quotes

[This message has been edited by TinyGirl (edited 01-28-2005).]

IP: Logged

rocyn
Housemate
posted 01-28-2005 03:38 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for rocyn   Click Here to Email rocyn     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Here's a question for y'all. Hubby and I have different last names (cuz mine is better). We're expecting in September. Anybody have kidlets with their spouse and chose not to give the kids the spouse's last name as well? Just pondering....

IP: Logged

greschya
Housemate
posted 01-28-2005 04:52 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for greschya   Click Here to Email greschya     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
emmalola did that, and we plan to do that as well. You know, when we have a reason to and all.

IP: Logged

ralphyr
Housemate
posted 01-28-2005 05:00 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for ralphyr   Click Here to Email ralphyr     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Thanks for clearing that one up, TinyGirl. One less thing to worry about. Hoping to have a friend play the wedding music on a harmonica for us.

About the parental names and child names. Part of the reason I'm taking hubbies is so the children have an easier time. If you have a different name from one parent people may assume that they are a step-parent. I might consider hyphenating our names if I could pronounce them quickly. I'm all about giving my kiddies the smoothest ride throught the bumpy trip that is life. It is of course MHO.

IP: Logged

txbyrd
Subletter
posted 02-24-2005 09:31 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for txbyrd     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I don't know if anyone is still reading this thread, and I've just registered so don't know anybody here. But I'm having a really hard time and would appreciate some comments.

I'm a woman in my fifties, recently married for the second time. First marriage was at age 23, lasted 17 years, followed by 10 years single, which included raising my youngest son alone. Met my now-husband four years ago, and have been with him since, married last Oct.

When I divorced my first husband, I resumed use of my maiden name. It felt SOO good to be "ME" again. I had never liked his name, and always felt like some kind of imposter. Hated when people would ask thing like, "Are you related to so-and-so?" and I'd have to say, "I have no idea, that's my husband's family ...."

Also, I am immensely proud of my family name, as it has been traced back to the 900s, and so represents a thousand years of blood and history.

But my husband, normally a gentle, kind, unassuming, very easygoing guy, really got adamant about me changing my name when we married, said he'd give in on about anything else but that, that we *had* to have the same name, that's how his parents did it, that's just how it was done. So I reluctantly acquiesced, with the caveat that I would keep my maiden name as a middle name, and USE all three names in the fashion of Hillary Rodham Clinton, etc.

Well, I've tried. I changed all my docs, etc. But no matter how emphatic I've been, things keep coming addressed to Myfirstname, Middleinitial, Hislastname. I've fought with my employer, magazine subscriptions and the cell phone company. It's largely a software problem, as computers are set up to deal ONLY with a first name, mi, and last name, period.

To me it's insulting, disrespectful and arrogant of these companies to arbitrarily change my middle name to an initial, especially when I have made it emphatically clear that is against my wishes. Now, even the SSA has done it. My SS card has my name right, but I've started getting mail from them, like the annual wage report, addressed to Myfname, Mi, Hislname, and they say they can't fix it, that's just the way the computer does it.

I cried for almost two hours last night. I feel SO bad. It's like I'm disappearing, being just wiped out. I can't face years and decades of this fight just to have MY NAME recognized and used and not disappear into his identity. And my husband sees how upset I am, but truly does not understand.

Has anyone ever heard of someone NOT getting divorced, but resuming their maiden name? How hard is it? YOu have to have a court order, right? Can a judge refuse you? Oh please, I would welcome any and all comments, I just feel so bad. Thank you.

Chris

IP: Logged

zazzera
Housemate
posted 02-24-2005 11:31 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for zazzera     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
My mother has changed her name 4 times. Only once was it b/c of divorce. The last time she changed it, she only changed her middle name (to her mother's maiden name). I don't remember the process ever seeming like much of a hassle, but I will ask her about it and get back to you.

Another option that might clear up the middle initial problem is what my sister-in-law did. Instead of using one last name as a middle name she took both as her last name. Yes, you can legally have 2 last names with no hyphen! It might cause more confusion in some circumstances, but might help with the initial issue on legal documents, etc.

IP: Logged

sneakers
Housesitter
posted 02-24-2005 11:33 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for sneakers     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hi Chris,and welcome to Digs!
I'm not sure about reversing stuff through courts, but maybe you could try to set things up to be recognized as two first names or two last names? A magazine subscription might come to Mary L. Smith, but if her name is Mary Lou is recognized as one first name and no middle name, it would come as Mary Lou Smith. Some places might smoosh the two together, but they'd be written out at least.

IP: Logged

ralphyr
Housemate
posted 02-24-2005 12:36 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for ralphyr   Click Here to Email ralphyr     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by txbyrd:
..... Also, I am immensely proud of my family name, as it has been traced back to the 900s, and so represents a thousand years of blood and history.

But my husband, normally a gentle, kind, unassuming, very easygoing guy, really got adamant about me changing my name when we married, said he'd give in on about anything else but that, that we *had* to have the same name, that's how his parents did it, that's just how it was done. So I reluctantly acquiesced, with the caveat that I would keep my maiden name as a middle name, and USE all three names in the fashion of Hillary Rodham Clinton, etc.
....
Oh please, I would welcome any and all comments, I just feel so bad. Thank you.

Chris



Hi Chris and welcome to the boards, threads have a habit of hanging round for ages, old ones get bumped all the time. It is like a conversation that you pickup from time to time.
Maybe if you and your husband could disuss his reasons and your reasons for the name change/no name change you might both become more at ease with the other's reasons and reach a compromise.
I assume you both have not discussed this beyond the fact that you *had* to have the same last names.
His reason sounds like conforming to convention and yours sounds like a more personal and deeply felt reason.

I don't feel like I have to take hubbies' name when I get married next month but I want to because;
We have been together 12 years and are getting married 'cause we want to.
My surname sounds like what you do after a big night out on the drink (think Chief Wiggam's son)
My new initials will be RAW.
I don't feel like it will make me feel *owned*.
Glad to *talk* to you.

IP: Logged

Dewgirl
Housesitter
posted 02-25-2005 08:07 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Dewgirl   Click Here to Email Dewgirl     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
heh... my initials (maiden name) were:

GAG

IP: Logged

BionicGirl
Housemate
posted 02-25-2005 08:34 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for BionicGirl   Click Here to Email BionicGirl     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
As far as I know, to legally change your name (first, middle, last, whatever), you just have to go through the SSA... like, go to the social security office and fill out a form and pay a fee. No court has to be involved at all. Then of course you have to notify everyone andchangeit on you bank accounts, etc.

IP: Logged

gemini
Housemate
posted 02-25-2005 10:17 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for gemini   Click Here to Email gemini     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by txbyrd:
I Has anyone ever heard of someone NOT getting divorced, but resuming their maiden name? How hard is it?


I have a friend who recently changed her name back without getting divorced. Her situation was very similar to yours. When she got married, she wanted to use both last names with no hypen. And like you have experienced, all documents would come back to her with a middle initial instead of the whole name--even her drivers license, even though she asked that they put her whole name on it.

It started to bother her enough that she eventually just changed her name back. It was no big deal, at least not legally a big deal. She just had to fill out some paperwork and pay some fees. I'm sure that it was a much bigger deal personally, though.

IP: Logged

txbyrd
Subletter
posted 02-25-2005 04:36 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for txbyrd     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Thank you all SO very much for your comments and the understanding that comes through your posts.

Zazzera, thanks for that input about being able to use two last names. I didn't know that; maybe that could be a solution - or two first names, or whatever.

Today another letter came addressed to both of us - this one didn't even bother with a middle intial. When I see that, it's just like a knife through my heart. I wish I could make him understand.

Well, since I see people are still alive on this thread :-) I'll keep monitoring it for awhile, while I try to think of what to do. Thanks again so much, all of you!

Chris

[This message has been edited by txbyrd (edited 02-25-2005).]

IP: Logged

crowjoy
Housemate
posted 02-25-2005 05:41 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for crowjoy   Click Here to Email crowjoy     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I don't know about changing your name back but if you're changing your name to something different, at least in my state, it's a court appearance and some cash to do so.

Have y'all talked about changing both of your names to yours? Then you would satisfy his top story for wanting you to take his, they'd both be the same. In any case I bet if you suggest this you'll get closer to the root of his real reasoning. Good luck!

IP: Logged

MoonMonkey
Subletter
posted 03-07-2005 12:16 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for MoonMonkey     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I'm getting married in a few months and we are planning to merge our names, as in "Mr. and Ms. PartOfHisLastNamePartOfHerLastName." I know it will take some explaining at first, but I think people will get used to it.

We talked a lot about the name issue when we got engaged, settling pretty quickly on the merging (he's a feminist, too,) before getting discouraged with the unwieldy combinations we initially came up with. What we finally decided on (after months of discussing ALL the possibilities - except the "Sonny and Cher" thing, whoever posted that is more creative than we are ) - is short and sweet, with only a few letters from each name, and it makes us happy.

Since we have yet to make this announcement to all but our closest family, we don't know how much heat we'll take, but we're prepared for it. I think the important thing is that couples go with something that feels right to them and stick with it. I'm bracing myself to correct the "Mr. and Mrs. HisFirstNameHisOldLastName"ers gently but firmly keeping in mind that I'm the one breaking with tradition/etiquette.

Actually, the biggest issue for me right now is addressing wedding invitations... I want to use the wording each person is most comfortable with, but don't know that for everyone... tempted to use guests' first names since our wedding is going to be casual, but I'm sure that's a big no-no. The last thing I'd want to do is default to the traditional way for people whose preferences I don't know - any thoughts on this?

IP: Logged

gemini
Housemate
posted 03-07-2005 04:38 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for gemini   Click Here to Email gemini     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by MoonMonkey:

Actually, the biggest issue for me right now is addressing wedding invitations... I want to use the wording each person is most comfortable with, but don't know that for everyone... tempted to use guests' first names since our wedding is going to be casual, but I'm sure that's a big no-no. The last thing I'd want to do is default to the traditional way for people whose preferences I don't know - any thoughts on this?


I generally address things (Xmas cards, etc) to "The Lastname Family" or to "The Lastnames." I just can't bring myself to ever address anything to Mr. and Mrs. Histfirstname Hislastname; it's just too archaic and silly to me.

If the couple have two different last names, I figure you'd be fine with first names since they clearly aren't hell-bent on tradition either.

Ultimately, though, I'd say do whatever makes you comfortable. I mean, it's your wedding; if the wording on your invitations makes them uncomfortable, they're gonna flip out about your name-changing decision. You might as well go ahead and start breaking them in with the non-traditional invitation addresses!

IP: Logged

audreypillow
Subletter
posted 03-09-2005 02:12 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for audreypillow     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hi, I'm here for the first time and this is a fascinating discussion.

I have been considering changing my surname to my mother's maiden name for several years. I have no relationship with my father, who left when I was very young. Even though my mother divorced my father when I was 2 yrs old, she kept his name (so we would have the same name) until recently (she waited a long time - I'm 27).

My mother's maiden name is a great ethnic name that I really like.

My issue is — I might get married someday and I don't want to deal (professionally) with two name changes, especially if the first one was not due to marriage. I am not sure if my boy and I will get hitched, but if we do I would LOVE to take his name. It is also a great ethnic name that has fantastic alliteration with my first name. Also, I do believe in the idea of sharing a name as a sign of unity. Plus, I am actually closer to his family than I am to my own.

I'm a writer and name recognition is important, so in spite of how backward this might sound, I am waiting to see if we get married before getting rid of my father's name.

Although - I haven't published much high-profile work yet, but when I do - hopefully soon! - I do NOT want my byline to be my given (father's) name.

Comments? Has anyone changed their name twice? Does anyone think it might not be that disastrous?

IP: Logged

ralphyr
Housemate
posted 03-09-2005 03:20 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for ralphyr   Click Here to Email ralphyr     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
audreypillow, could you change your name to boys name now. That would be the most practical solution if you think you'll get married. That way you'll only have to change your name once and not run the risk of the wrong name becoming famous.

IP: Logged

dcgrrrl1979
Housemate
posted 03-09-2005 08:09 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for dcgrrrl1979     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Audrey, what about having a writing name and an everyday name? There are scores of talented writers - both male and female - who have used pen names.

IP: Logged

cool0110
Housemate
posted 03-09-2005 09:16 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for cool0110     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Ooh, good question, Pillow!
How about if you make up an awesome sounding pen-name and only use it professionally (but not legally). Then, if you get married and want to change your legal name, do it then.

IP: Logged

audreypillow
Subletter
posted 03-11-2005 01:38 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for audreypillow     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Thanks for the responses!

I wouldn't take my boy's last name unless we got married... We are still working out whether we want to marry or just have a long-term partnership.

I like the idea of using a pen name professionally. If I do, it would be "Audrey Pillow."

Does anyone have thoughts on how that sounds? It fits my personality, but what does it conjure up for strangers? (I write in the fields of art/design/fashion).

It would be great if Audrey Pillow becomes famous, but at this stage, my "real name" recognition seems quite important because I am trying to parlay freelance writing into a full-time job.

Arrg.:;

IP: Logged

crowjoy
Housemate
posted 03-25-2005 12:27 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for crowjoy   Click Here to Email crowjoy     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Bumping for the last Casanova!

IP: Logged

tippygee
Housemate
posted 03-25-2005 01:23 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for tippygee     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by audreypillow:
Thanks for the responses!

I wouldn't take my boy's last name unless we got married... We are still working out whether we want to marry or just have a long-term partnership.

I like the idea of using a pen name professionally. If I do, it would be "Audrey Pillow."

Does anyone have thoughts on how that sounds? It fits my personality, but what does it conjure up for strangers? (I write in the fields of art/design/fashion).

It would be great if Audrey Pillow becomes famous, but at this stage, my "real name" recognition seems quite important because I am trying to parlay freelance writing into a full-time job.

Arrg.:;



I realize this was like a couple of weeks ago, but audrey, here's a thought--not all pen names are completely made up. Mine, for example is my name before I was adopted, which I like because it gives a nod to my foster family who tried to adopt me and weren't allowed to, and yet who invested eight long months of rasing and infant and over twenty more years of love, and gifts and extra familiness. So why not take on your mother's name professionally, as your writing name. Then you'd never change that name, it would get to be yours, and people would know you by that name. Then when and if the marriage time comes, you be come "Mrs. Boyslastname" for all other purposes, and "Audrey Momslastname" for your writing. Then yould get to have both last names that you love with minimal crazy last name changing.

IP: Logged

hermitclare
Housesitter
posted 03-25-2005 02:46 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for hermitclare   Click Here to Email hermitclare     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Posted in another thread:

quote:
Originally posted by nicocasanova:
Hi,

I read through many of your posts and am still confused. I have a major attachment to my last name, Casanova. I love it! My sister and I are the last Casanova's in the family... my family is from Genoa, Italy... and I like all the noteriety that comes with the name. I'm sure that I'm attached to my former party girl persona and the name represents alot of that. I never thought I'd give it up. My boyfriend is Korean and very traditional and wants me to take his. He's cool with me keeping mine for professional purposes. It just seems like such a hassle to deal to make the change and such a hassle to keep it when kids come into the picture.
There's a part of me that believes that if I let it go, I'll release the last bit of my former self and that a new better me will show up...

but as I said, for so long it's been my identity and I'm really sad to let it go.

Is it easier to bite the bullet and take his name than it is to maintain 2 names in different situations? If I make Casanova my middle name, I'm basically mrs. lee then, right?

hmmm..


quote:
Originally posted by crowjoy:
Hi Nico, this will probably get moved to the existing "change your name" thread and I'll bump it for you.

But my first thought is, can you make Lee your middle name? Then he can introduce you as Mrs. Lee but you can keep your legal name Casanova. Then you could reverse it for the kids?


quote:
Originally posted by nicocasanova:
Interesting- I've read so many posts and most of the women move their maiden name to the middle... I've never seen it reversed.

Will present that option- thanks!


IP: Logged

Beach
Housemate
posted 03-25-2005 03:10 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Beach   Click Here to Email Beach     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
This is the question that always seems to pop into my head - why don't the guys ever go through this gut-wrenching decision about letting go of a piece of them/their history/their connection?

I realize that some guys are 'tradtional' but does that give them a free ride on these issues?

I see a ton of options but most importantly I think you should do what you want in the end: it's your name, you have to live with it not the boy.
1) have HIM take YOUR last name
2) you take his last name
3) you both have two last names (hyphonated or not)
4) take his last name as your middle name
5) have him take your last name as his middle name
6) pick a new last name together
?

As much as your boy has a right to want to be traditional you equally have a right to want no part of that tradition. Don't give his viewpoint more weight just because 'that's the way it's been done' - generally that's a pretty poor reason to do anything.

IP: Logged

attentionmonster
Housemate
posted 04-06-2005 07:43 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for attentionmonster   Click Here to Email attentionmonster     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
this is a cool thread. I always thought I would keep my own name, until I got married and it seemed divisive to not change it.

On my sscard it's KLW. At first I used KRW (my middle name's R). This was mainly because I despised my dad for a while and had thoughts of using my mom's maiden name, A.

I also don't really know any part of my dad's family as well as I know my mom's (I met his dad *once* when I was very small), so I have no real attachment to L other than having it as my last name for almost 21 years before getting married. Then I got irritated by my old self disappearing and started using KLW all the time -at work, new bank accounts, etc. I'm still KRL, I'm just married to JW.

Wow, I'm so homesick now, and proud of my family!

Oh, and W is a cool last name. It fits in with my love of nature. People misspell it, though; how do you misspell a name that is only five letters long?!

[This message has been edited by attentionmonster (edited 04-06-2005).]

IP: Logged

bluecore
Housemate
posted 04-07-2005 07:44 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for bluecore     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I'm definitely taking his name. I'm not attached to my last name, seeing as I didn't really even know my father. I think the last name of whomever I decide to marry will carry more meaning to me.I hope the boy & I will last through the tough times... I really like his last name. Though, I assure you, I will be marrying him for more valid reasons than that.

IP: Logged

geogirl
Housemate
posted 04-07-2005 08:10 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for geogirl     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
My boy has always joked that he would take my name & use his as his middle name. But that is just so his name would be (common name starting with St V last name of author named Garth). So he would have the same name as the girl from Fleetwood Mac.

IP: Logged

TinyGirl
Housemate
posted 04-07-2005 10:21 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for TinyGirl     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I've been thinking about this as the boy and I are starting to talk about kids, etc...
I DO NOT want to change my name. When I lived in the monastery/convent(see "Why I hate my SO" thread for more) I didn't go by my first name because I went by my paton saint name-so I was Sr. HolyName. Giving up my real true identity that way and then trying to regain it when I left was very painful and affected me in ways that I didn't fully understand--for example, TinyGirl could behave one way, HolyName couldn't, etc. Then I realized I'm the same person and I don't need two identities. So, if I took boy's name, I am afraid that I would be giving up my identity the same way I did before, and I do not want to do that. I just don't know what we'd do if/when we had kids only because I think family unity (through a name) is cool. And if people hyphenate, do BOTH people? I mean of couse they COULD, but is the mom/wife/partner the odd one? Like TinyGirl Mylast-Hislast and everybody else Hislast? Seriously, this makes my head spin.

And I'm bitter I even have to consider this. I've never in my life, even amongst my liberal college friends, heard one single male say "Oh, I don't know, maybe changing my last name would give a sense of family unity" or anything. Humph. And I've heard things like "Oh, the baby's name is Lucy Marie? What a nice neutral name! It will go with anything when she's married!" WTF? And then I wonder, did my parents think about this for me? Argh!!!

IP: Logged

geogirl
Housemate
posted 04-07-2005 10:48 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for geogirl     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I don't know about general rules, but I've known people w/ hyphenated last names as children (littleboy mom's maiden-dad's)

IP: Logged

ejwarner
Subletter
posted 05-25-2005 03:29 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for ejwarner     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I am getting married in two weeks. I have not yet chosen what my name will be. I have thought of having both names. I was considering just taking his name. The only problem is, he has been married before and there is already someone with his last name. This is my dilemma. I do not want to give up my identity, but the thought of having the same name is nice except for the fact someone already has it. Someone help me out.

IP: Logged

Mirinae
Subletter
posted 05-26-2005 06:07 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Mirinae     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
What an interesting thread! My social group has a number of name combinations, so I thought I'd share them.

First off, I intend to take my husband's name when I marry. It's funny; I had always intended to keep my maiden name, because my sister and I are the last generation with our family name, and I didn't want to see it lost. (It's a common last name -- in England, anyway, which is where my family is from -- but we're the last of *our* family.) However, I really like my partner's last name, and I like the idea of unifying with him (and I know he is far, far too traditional to take MY name instead). Also, my boyfriend's father was adopted, so in a way we're honouring his adoptive grandparents by keeping the last name. His last name is more important to him than mine is to me, so I'll take his name. That being said, I intend to continue using my maiden name as my pen name (I've yet to be published, but I am a writer); that way, I continue to honour my family and keep the name going (in a sense, it's almost more permanent than having children), and my name is alliterative, so it sounds really ... well, writerly.

Now, on to other examples in my social group.

I have friends who were married a few years ago. The wife, C, was adopted, and her last name was very, very important to her: it was the first "gift" her adoptive parents ever gave her. The husband, T, was also fond of his last name, for reasons very similar to my own: he was the last of his family, and wanted to keep the name going. So, when C and T got married, they both hyphenated their last names, so they're Mr. and Mrs. C & T Jones-Smith. I've always found that very sweet.

My married roommates both have different last names. The wife, H, didn't have any particular reason for keeping her last name (although she too is adopted); she just didn't feel like going through the hassle of changing it. And it comes in handy when telemarketers call, because if they ask for Mr. Jones (the wife's last name) we can say there's no-one by that name in the house.

Finally, I have friends who were married but are now divorced. The ex-wife has chosen to keep her married name (she took her husband's name when they married), although the divorce has been quite bitter. Her maiden name was long and complicated and very often misspelled, and her ex-husband's name was short (four letters!) and easy to say. So, while she holds no love for him OR his name, she's keeping it because it's easier than her maiden name.

Phew! That was a long post!

IP: Logged

becca11
Housesitter
posted 05-26-2005 06:16 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for becca11     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by ejwarner:
I am getting married in two weeks. I have not yet chosen what my name will be. I have thought of having both names. I was considering just taking his name. The only problem is, he has been married before and there is already someone with his last name. This is my dilemma. I do not want to give up my identity, but the thought of having the same name is nice except for the fact someone already has it. Someone help me out.

I'm in exactly the same boat. I thought she'd gone back to her maiden name but I saw her name on a recent travel document and no. I know that her kdis go by my boys lastname so she'll probably stick with it but I think in order for my (future) kids to have the same name as me, and share boys name we'll have to hypenate. But, it's an ugly combo.

IP: Logged

meggo
Housemate
posted 05-26-2005 07:48 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for meggo   Click Here to Email meggo     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Mirinae:
Finally, I have friends who were married but are now divorced. The ex-wife has chosen to keep her married name (she took her husband's name when they married), although the divorce has been quite bitter. Her maiden name was long and complicated and very often misspelled, and her ex-husband's name was short (four letters!) and easy to say. So, while she holds no love for him OR his name, she's keeping it because it's easier than her maiden name.

I have a friend who, when going through her divorce a little over a year ago - swore she'd keep her married name (let's say Jones) because that was their daughters last name & she couldn't fathom having a different last name than her daughter.
Fast forward to Sunday - she got remarried on Sunday to a man whose last name is Smith and she's taking his last name.
I was trying to figure out how she'd manage to have Smith's last name AND Jones' last name (for her daughter).
She's deleted her middle name and made her ex husbands last name her new middle name.
So rather than being Sarah Anne Jones, she's now Sarah Jones Smith.
Which I just find odd considering her ex is quite the schmuck - and it also confirms my decision to keep my name so I don't have to go through all of that.

IP: Logged

SeaJay
Housemate
posted 05-26-2005 08:02 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for SeaJay   Click Here to Email SeaJay     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I have a friend who has kept her husband's name after divorce, despite the fact that the divorce was bitter, occurred over ten years ago, and there are no particular advantages to one surname over the other (both are very common Welsh surnames, both are very short). She says it was just too much hassle to change after the divorce, and there was never a point at which she wanted to call attention to the fact that she'd been divorced because the whole thing was so painful to deal with anyway without inviting more speculation, so she kept it.

I can see her point of view, but I'm not sure that the temporary problem of changing your surname is greater than the now permanent problem of having replaced your own surname with that of someone you resent enormously.

IP: Logged


This topic is 8 pages long:   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8 

All times are PT (US)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | DigsMagazine


Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47d