we got it all wrong? jump
to the discussion
and sound off!
Directed by: Chris Eyre
Written by: Sherman Alexie
Starring: Adam Beach, Evan Adams, Irene
Look for it at the video store under: drama, comedy
the rating system explained
Slice of life movie about two Indian (Native
American) teens from a reservation. Victor and Thomas road-trip to
Phoenix to retrieve the ashes of Victorís deceased father. Victor is a
tough basketball playing kid, and Thomas is the nerdy one who
(supposedly) has the ability to tell great stories. Along the way, they
(supposedly) discover things about themselves as well as secrets of
their pasts, and we (supposedly) learn about reservation life and
of life" is a term usually applied after viewing for a movie that
went nowhere. When you canít figure out what the hellís going on,
only to realize that, oh, nothingís going on, you call it a slice of
life. Or "character piece." No exception here. Itís billed
as the first movie produced and written by Native Americans -- great, itís
quite an achievement to get a film made. And, from what Iím told,
fairly accurate of reservation life. But it doesnít mean itís any
good. Itís not necessarily bad, as in "Pallbearer"
bad, or "Godzilla" bad, but Friday night laze viewing
it ainít. Donít get on my case for being un-PC here. I rented this
based on all sorts of great reviews. Boy, do critics have a completely
different agenda in movie-watching. I guess "enjoyable,"
"entertaining," and "worth the rental fee" are three
criteria that are absent from their judging lists. The storyís from a
book, and you can tell. Itís full of (from what I gather) metaphors,
but it just doesnít translate. Thomas is supposed to be a great
storyteller, able to mesmerize all who hear his tales, but, frankly, heís
just annoying, and his stories are ridiculous. Twenty
into this movie, the "ugggghs" and forceful sighs of
"what the hellís going on?" could be heard in my living room
(and not just from me). The story meandered with no discernible
direction, and before I knew it, weíre watching a scene of Indians vs.
Jesuits in a 2-on-2 basketball game. Huh? Unless you have a burning
academic interest in reservation life, or youíre just out of Nyquil,
donít get this movie. ĎCause I didnít.
ó reviewed by Steve Loh
Loh writes in LA. Prior to that, he held every odd
character-building job between college and grad school and life, including
temping, driving a schoolbus, substitute teaching, and being a birthday
party clown for the kids of rich Hollywood folk. Barney was his least
favorite costume and, unfortunately, the most requested.
lounge . nourish
. host .
. home .